Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast Fri, 17 Jul 2026 08:32:07 -0400 http://www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com en © 2026 Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast yes Support this Podcast 5d6ae087-96ad-5ba7-94ca-b8edd632a0ba tragedyatruecrimepodcast@gmail.com Michael and Alyssa McFarland episodic false We are dedicated to sharing the stories of the victims and families that have experienced tragic losses or events. We want their stories heard by as many people as possible so as to never forget them and what they meant to the people in their lives.


If you have questions about an episode or would like us to consider a new case, please contact us through Facebook or email us at tragedyatruecrimepodcast@gmail.com

]]> Buzzsprout (https://www.buzzsprout.com) Michael and Alyssa McFarland tragedyatruecrimepodcast@gmail.com https://storage.buzzsprout.com/1yop6su4v9v4all0k8nqnfyp7ynp?.jpg Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast http://www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com S2E32 - Standing Beside the Search: Luke Twardowski on Loving Someone Who Won't Give Up S2E32 - Standing Beside the Search: Luke Twardowski on Loving Someone Who Won't Give Up For more than three decades, the search for answers in Deanna Merryfield's disappearance has shaped the lives of everyone who loves her. But what is it like to marry into a family carrying that kind of heartbreak?

In this episode, we sit down with Luke Twardowski, husband of Deanna's sister, Melissa, for a deeply personal conversation about what it's like to witness tragedy from the outside before becoming part of it. Luke shares his perspective on watching Melissa dedicate years of her life to advocating for her sister, the emotional toll that pursuit of justice has taken on their family, and why he has chosen to stand beside her every step of the way.

Together, we discuss the challenges families face when they refuse to let a loved one be forgotten, the importance of community support, and Luke's thoughts on what law enforcement needs to move Deanna's case forward. We also explore how this journey has changed his own outlook on justice, perseverance, and the responsibility we all share in helping solve cold cases.

If someone knows what happened to Deanna Merryfield, the answers are still out there. Sometimes, all it takes is one person deciding it's finally time to speak.


Music License - CBTOH3OXKQ0G0YW5

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> For more than three decades, the search for answers in Deanna Merryfield's disappearance has shaped the lives of everyone who loves her. But what is it like to marry into a family carrying that kind of heartbreak?

In this episode, we sit down with Luke Twardowski, husband of Deanna's sister, Melissa, for a deeply personal conversation about what it's like to witness tragedy from the outside before becoming part of it. Luke shares his perspective on watching Melissa dedicate years of her life to advocating for her sister, the emotional toll that pursuit of justice has taken on their family, and why he has chosen to stand beside her every step of the way.

Together, we discuss the challenges families face when they refuse to let a loved one be forgotten, the importance of community support, and Luke's thoughts on what law enforcement needs to move Deanna's case forward. We also explore how this journey has changed his own outlook on justice, perseverance, and the responsibility we all share in helping solve cold cases.

If someone knows what happened to Deanna Merryfield, the answers are still out there. Sometimes, all it takes is one person deciding it's finally time to speak.


Music License - CBTOH3OXKQ0G0YW5

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19437461 Fri, 10 Jul 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2905 Deanna Merryfield, Luke Twardowski, Melissa Twardowski, true crime, cold case, missing person, victim advocacy, law enforcement, unsolved mystery, justice 2 32 full false S2E31 - BONUS - The Best Defense: Staying Aware with Mark Fricke S2E31 - BONUS - The Best Defense: Staying Aware with Mark Fricke In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we sit down with Mark Fricke, a former law enforcement officer and personal safety trainer, to discuss the practical skills that can help keep you from becoming a victim. Drawing from decades of real-world experience, Mark shares how situational awareness, preparation, and everyday habits can dramatically improve your personal safety.

We explore the warning signs that are often overlooked, how criminals identify potential victims, and simple strategies anyone can use to become more aware of their surroundings. Mark also offers practical guidance on what to do if you find yourself in a dangerous situation, how to make quick decisions under stress, and why confidence and preparation can be powerful deterrents.

This conversation isn't about living in fear—it's about living with awareness. Whether you're walking through a parking lot, traveling alone, or simply going about your daily routine, the lessons in this episode could help you protect yourself and those you love.

Join us for an informative discussion that empowers listeners with knowledge, confidence, and practical tools for staying safe in an unpredictable world.


Music License - ACIM74WYHELEYIVF

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we sit down with Mark Fricke, a former law enforcement officer and personal safety trainer, to discuss the practical skills that can help keep you from becoming a victim. Drawing from decades of real-world experience, Mark shares how situational awareness, preparation, and everyday habits can dramatically improve your personal safety.

We explore the warning signs that are often overlooked, how criminals identify potential victims, and simple strategies anyone can use to become more aware of their surroundings. Mark also offers practical guidance on what to do if you find yourself in a dangerous situation, how to make quick decisions under stress, and why confidence and preparation can be powerful deterrents.

This conversation isn't about living in fear—it's about living with awareness. Whether you're walking through a parking lot, traveling alone, or simply going about your daily routine, the lessons in this episode could help you protect yourself and those you love.

Join us for an informative discussion that empowers listeners with knowledge, confidence, and practical tools for staying safe in an unpredictable world.


Music License - ACIM74WYHELEYIVF

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19455168 Mon, 06 Jul 2026 18:00:00 -0400 2763 personal safety, situational awareness, crime prevention, self defense, personal security, victim prevention, law enforcement, Mark Fricke, true crime podcast, safety tips 2 31 full false S2E30 - The Path to Answers: Investigator Steve Gelinske on the Deanna Merryfield Case S2E30 - The Path to Answers: Investigator Steve Gelinske on the Deanna Merryfield Case More than three decades after Deanna Merryfield disappeared from Killeen, Texas, the search for answers continues. In this special episode, we sit down with private investigator Steve Gelinske, who has devoted countless hours to reviewing the case and following the evidence wherever it leads.

Steve shares what he can safely discuss about the investigation, offering listeners a rare look into the challenges of working a cold case where memories have faded, records are incomplete, and every new lead must be carefully evaluated. He explains why patience matters, why investigations cannot be rushed, and how even the smallest detail can become the key that unlocks the truth.

We also discuss the responsibility investigators carry, the importance of separating fact from rumor, and why community involvement remains essential after all these years.

Most importantly, we want anyone who lived in Killeen, knew Deanna, or remembers anything from that time to know this: this case is solvable. Someone out there knows something. A memory, a conversation, or a detail once dismissed as insignificant may be exactly what is needed to bring answers to Deanna's family.

If you know something, now is the time to speak. Thirty years may have passed, but the pursuit of truth never expires.


Music License - ZU8JVNFJJXCKNSRD

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> More than three decades after Deanna Merryfield disappeared from Killeen, Texas, the search for answers continues. In this special episode, we sit down with private investigator Steve Gelinske, who has devoted countless hours to reviewing the case and following the evidence wherever it leads.

Steve shares what he can safely discuss about the investigation, offering listeners a rare look into the challenges of working a cold case where memories have faded, records are incomplete, and every new lead must be carefully evaluated. He explains why patience matters, why investigations cannot be rushed, and how even the smallest detail can become the key that unlocks the truth.

We also discuss the responsibility investigators carry, the importance of separating fact from rumor, and why community involvement remains essential after all these years.

Most importantly, we want anyone who lived in Killeen, knew Deanna, or remembers anything from that time to know this: this case is solvable. Someone out there knows something. A memory, a conversation, or a detail once dismissed as insignificant may be exactly what is needed to bring answers to Deanna's family.

If you know something, now is the time to speak. Thirty years may have passed, but the pursuit of truth never expires.


Music License - ZU8JVNFJJXCKNSRD

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19380831 Fri, 03 Jul 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2560 Deanna Merryfield, Steve Gelinske, Killeen Texas, cold case, missing persons, private investigator, unsolved mystery, true crime podcast, Bell County Texas, victim advocacy 2 30 full false S2E29 - Still Searching: Melissa Twardowski and the Fight for Deanna S2E29 - Still Searching: Melissa Twardowski and the Fight for Deanna More than three decades after the disappearance of Deanna Merryfield, her family continues to search for answers. In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, Michael and Alyssa sit down with Deanna’s youngest sister, Melissa Twardowski, to revisit the case and examine the publicly available evidence that has kept hope alive.

Together, they retrace the events surrounding Deanna’s disappearance, discuss how perceptions of the case have evolved over the years, and explore the powerful role that social media and online communities have played in renewing interest in the investigation. Melissa shares personal memories, the impact of living with unanswered questions, and why she remains committed to ensuring her sister’s story is never forgotten.

This conversation is a reminder that time does not diminish love, and that sometimes a community united by compassion can help keep a search for truth alive.


Music License - VCFRGND561WHCVYS

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> More than three decades after the disappearance of Deanna Merryfield, her family continues to search for answers. In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, Michael and Alyssa sit down with Deanna’s youngest sister, Melissa Twardowski, to revisit the case and examine the publicly available evidence that has kept hope alive.

Together, they retrace the events surrounding Deanna’s disappearance, discuss how perceptions of the case have evolved over the years, and explore the powerful role that social media and online communities have played in renewing interest in the investigation. Melissa shares personal memories, the impact of living with unanswered questions, and why she remains committed to ensuring her sister’s story is never forgotten.

This conversation is a reminder that time does not diminish love, and that sometimes a community united by compassion can help keep a search for truth alive.


Music License - VCFRGND561WHCVYS

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19376041 Fri, 26 Jun 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1456 Deanna Merryfield,Melissa Twardowski,missing persons,true crime podcast,cold case,unsolved mystery,Killeen Texas,missing person investigation,social media advocacy,family search for answers 2 29 full false S2E28 - Finding Deanna Merryfield: Thirty-Five Years of Refusing to Forget S2E28 - Finding Deanna Merryfield: Thirty-Five Years of Refusing to Forget In July 1990, 13-year-old Deanna Merryfield disappeared from Killeen, Texas. Her case was quickly labeled a runaway, and like so many missing children of that era, the investigation faded while the years marched on. But for Deanna's family, especially her younger sister Melissa, the search never stopped.

More than three decades later, renewed efforts, new leads, and a growing public awareness are breathing life into a case that many assumed had been lost to history. Melissa has spent years fighting for answers, determined that her sister's name would not become just another forgotten file.

In this episode, we explore the circumstances surrounding Deanna's disappearance, the failures that left critical questions unanswered, and the unwavering devotion of a sister who refuses to let Deanna's story disappear. Because no matter how much time has passed, every child deserves to be found, and every family deserves answers. 

After 35 years, the search continues. And as long as Melissa keeps fighting, Deanna Merryfield's story will never be forgotten.


Music License - 8BOHMIK2F3WNVOGA, I1LO8WMBHOUOJM18

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In July 1990, 13-year-old Deanna Merryfield disappeared from Killeen, Texas. Her case was quickly labeled a runaway, and like so many missing children of that era, the investigation faded while the years marched on. But for Deanna's family, especially her younger sister Melissa, the search never stopped.

More than three decades later, renewed efforts, new leads, and a growing public awareness are breathing life into a case that many assumed had been lost to history. Melissa has spent years fighting for answers, determined that her sister's name would not become just another forgotten file.

In this episode, we explore the circumstances surrounding Deanna's disappearance, the failures that left critical questions unanswered, and the unwavering devotion of a sister who refuses to let Deanna's story disappear. Because no matter how much time has passed, every child deserves to be found, and every family deserves answers. 

After 35 years, the search continues. And as long as Melissa keeps fighting, Deanna Merryfield's story will never be forgotten.


Music License - 8BOHMIK2F3WNVOGA, I1LO8WMBHOUOJM18

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19365068 Fri, 19 Jun 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1090 Deanna Merryfield, Missing Person, Cold Case, Killeen Texas, True Crime Podcast, Unsolved Mystery, Missing Children, Family Advocacy, Melissa Merryfield, Victim Advocacy 2 28 full false S2E27 - The Final Chapter: Krystle Cook, CrimeCon 2026, and What Comes Next S2E27 - The Final Chapter: Krystle Cook, CrimeCon 2026, and What Comes Next In the final installment of our coverage of the Krystle Cook case, we take a step back to reflect on the journey that has brought us here. From the initial investigation and search for answers to the voices of family members, advocates, and those who have stood beside Krystle's loved ones, this case has left a lasting impact on everyone involved—including us.

In this episode, we share updates and conversations from CrimeCon 2026, revisit the key events and unanswered questions surrounding Krystle's case, and discuss what we've learned throughout this process. We also take an honest look at how covering this story has shaped our approach to true crime storytelling, victim advocacy, and our responsibilities as hosts.

More than a case review, this episode is a reflection on the people behind the headlines, the importance of listening to victims' families, and the lessons that will guide the future of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast.

Thank you to everyone who joined us on this journey, shared their experiences, and helped keep Krystle's story alive. While this may be the final chapter in our coverage, her legacy—and the impact she continues to have—will not be forgotten.


Music License - 9REI3RNS8AJMZE6U

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In the final installment of our coverage of the Krystle Cook case, we take a step back to reflect on the journey that has brought us here. From the initial investigation and search for answers to the voices of family members, advocates, and those who have stood beside Krystle's loved ones, this case has left a lasting impact on everyone involved—including us.

In this episode, we share updates and conversations from CrimeCon 2026, revisit the key events and unanswered questions surrounding Krystle's case, and discuss what we've learned throughout this process. We also take an honest look at how covering this story has shaped our approach to true crime storytelling, victim advocacy, and our responsibilities as hosts.

More than a case review, this episode is a reflection on the people behind the headlines, the importance of listening to victims' families, and the lessons that will guide the future of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast.

Thank you to everyone who joined us on this journey, shared their experiences, and helped keep Krystle's story alive. While this may be the final chapter in our coverage, her legacy—and the impact she continues to have—will not be forgotten.


Music License - 9REI3RNS8AJMZE6U

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19323679 Fri, 12 Jun 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1377 Krystle Cook, CrimeCon 2026, victim advocacy, true crime podcast, parole hearing, victims' rights, cold case awareness, family impact, justice system, co-victims, survivor stories, true crime community, podcast reflection, crime victims, Tragedy A True Cr 2 27 full true S2E26 - A Love That Chose the Journey: Heather Cook's Story of Family, Loss, and Legacy S2E26 - A Love That Chose the Journey: Heather Cook's Story of Family, Loss, and Legacy When Heather Cook entered Lee Cook's life, she stepped into a family forever changed by tragedy. In this deeply personal conversation, Heather shares what it was like joining a family still searching for answers about Krystle's disappearance and how she and Lee navigated the uncertainty, heartbreak, and determination that defined those years.

Heather reflects on the bond she built with Lee during the search for Krystle, the strength she witnessed within the Cook family, and the emotional toll of standing beside loved ones pursuing justice. She also opens up about attending the parole hearing, the difficult emotions that surfaced throughout the process, and the lasting impact of advocating for someone she never had the opportunity to meet.

Though Heather never knew Krystle personally, her absence has profoundly shaped Heather's life and her understanding of love, grief, resilience, and the enduring fight for justice. This episode offers a unique perspective on how violent crime affects not only those who knew the victim, but also those who later become part of the family's journey.

Join us as Heather shares her story of supporting a family through unimaginable loss while honoring the memory of a woman she came to know through the people who loved her most.


Music License - MMYP7GQYIPNSJGKR

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> When Heather Cook entered Lee Cook's life, she stepped into a family forever changed by tragedy. In this deeply personal conversation, Heather shares what it was like joining a family still searching for answers about Krystle's disappearance and how she and Lee navigated the uncertainty, heartbreak, and determination that defined those years.

Heather reflects on the bond she built with Lee during the search for Krystle, the strength she witnessed within the Cook family, and the emotional toll of standing beside loved ones pursuing justice. She also opens up about attending the parole hearing, the difficult emotions that surfaced throughout the process, and the lasting impact of advocating for someone she never had the opportunity to meet.

Though Heather never knew Krystle personally, her absence has profoundly shaped Heather's life and her understanding of love, grief, resilience, and the enduring fight for justice. This episode offers a unique perspective on how violent crime affects not only those who knew the victim, but also those who later become part of the family's journey.

Join us as Heather shares her story of supporting a family through unimaginable loss while honoring the memory of a woman she came to know through the people who loved her most.


Music License - MMYP7GQYIPNSJGKR

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19284753 Fri, 05 Jun 2026 08:00:00 -0400 3058 Krystle Cook, Heather Cook, Lee Cook, victim advocacy, parole hearing, true crime, family loss, grief, justice, victims rights, co-victims, murder victim advocacy, surviving family members, crime victims, parole process, healing after tragedy, advocacy 2 26 full false S2E25 - Pain into Purpose: Our Conversation with Lori Williams, Krystle Cook's Aunt S2E25 - Pain into Purpose: Our Conversation with Lori Williams, Krystle Cook's Aunt In this emotional and deeply personal episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we sit down with Lori Williams, Krystle’s aunt, as she shares the painful reality of reliving trauma during the parole hearing process and the emotional toll that violent crime continues to have on surviving family members years later. Lori opens up about the challenges of navigating victim advocacy, the frustration many co-victims experience when communication breaks down, and the lessons she has learned about supporting one another through unimaginable grief.

We also discuss organizations that provide critical support for families affected by homicide, including Parents of Murdered Children (POMC), a national organization offering emotional support, advocacy resources, and guidance for survivors of violent crime. Lori reflects on how resources like these can help families find connection, understanding, and purpose in the aftermath of tragedy.

This episode is a powerful conversation about grief, resilience, advocacy, and turning pain into purpose.


Music License - WFJJWLV9SCCIXM4F

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this emotional and deeply personal episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we sit down with Lori Williams, Krystle’s aunt, as she shares the painful reality of reliving trauma during the parole hearing process and the emotional toll that violent crime continues to have on surviving family members years later. Lori opens up about the challenges of navigating victim advocacy, the frustration many co-victims experience when communication breaks down, and the lessons she has learned about supporting one another through unimaginable grief.

We also discuss organizations that provide critical support for families affected by homicide, including Parents of Murdered Children (POMC), a national organization offering emotional support, advocacy resources, and guidance for survivors of violent crime. Lori reflects on how resources like these can help families find connection, understanding, and purpose in the aftermath of tragedy.

This episode is a powerful conversation about grief, resilience, advocacy, and turning pain into purpose.


Music License - WFJJWLV9SCCIXM4F

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19217857 Fri, 29 May 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2344 true crime, Krystle Cook, Lori Williams, pain into purpose, victim advocacy, co-victims, parole hearing, violent crime, grief, trauma, surviving family members, Parents of Murdered Children, POMC, homicide survivors, justice system, victim rights, emotion 2 25 full false S2E24 - BONUS - Beyond the Story: Checking In with Season One Guests S2E24 - BONUS - Beyond the Story: Checking In with Season One Guests In this special bonus episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we reconnect with three guests from Season One to hear what's happened since they first shared their stories with us.

For many families affected by violent crime, missing loved ones, or an unsolved case, life doesn't simply move on when an episode ends. The search for answers, the fight for justice, and the daily reality of loss continue long after the public attention fades.

Our guests provide updates on their cases, discuss the impact that victim advocates have had on their journeys, and share the challenges they still face today. Their stories highlight both the importance of having someone in your corner and the strength it takes to keep moving forward when justice feels uncertain.

This conversation is a reminder that these aren't just cases—they're real people living with the consequences every day. Join us as we revisit their stories, celebrate progress where it has been made, and recognize the ongoing struggles that often remain unseen.


Music License - GA0GDHFIY82P43WQ

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this special bonus episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we reconnect with three guests from Season One to hear what's happened since they first shared their stories with us.

For many families affected by violent crime, missing loved ones, or an unsolved case, life doesn't simply move on when an episode ends. The search for answers, the fight for justice, and the daily reality of loss continue long after the public attention fades.

Our guests provide updates on their cases, discuss the impact that victim advocates have had on their journeys, and share the challenges they still face today. Their stories highlight both the importance of having someone in your corner and the strength it takes to keep moving forward when justice feels uncertain.

This conversation is a reminder that these aren't just cases—they're real people living with the consequences every day. Join us as we revisit their stories, celebrate progress where it has been made, and recognize the ongoing struggles that often remain unseen.


Music License - GA0GDHFIY82P43WQ

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19256716 Thu, 28 May 2026 19:00:00 -0400 3088 true crime, victim advocacy, victims rights, justice, missing persons, cold cases, unsolved mysteries, family stories, crime victims, advocacy, survivor stories, criminal justice, grief, healing, case updates, season one, true crime podcast, tragedy podca 2 24 full false S2E23 - Justice Beyond the Sentence: Hannah Mosbrucker Speaks for Krystle S2E23 - Justice Beyond the Sentence: Hannah Mosbrucker Speaks for Krystle In this emotional and deeply personal interview, Hannah Mosbrucker shares the lasting impact of losing her sister, Krystle Cook, and the painful reality of navigating life after tragedy. Hannah opens up about the nonprofit created in Krystle’s honor, the mission behind their advocacy work, and the ongoing fight to support victims’ families facing similar heartbreak.

She also discusses the emotional toll of the parole board process, the frustration many families experience within the justice system, and what it feels like to repeatedly relive unimaginable loss while fighting to keep a victim’s voice alive. Through grief, resilience, and determination, Hannah offers an honest look at the lifelong impact violent crime leaves on surviving families.

This episode continues our exploration into the Krystle Cook case and the people carrying her legacy forward in the pursuit of justice, awareness, and change.


Music License - HUN48UZPYPFFFR0R

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this emotional and deeply personal interview, Hannah Mosbrucker shares the lasting impact of losing her sister, Krystle Cook, and the painful reality of navigating life after tragedy. Hannah opens up about the nonprofit created in Krystle’s honor, the mission behind their advocacy work, and the ongoing fight to support victims’ families facing similar heartbreak.

She also discusses the emotional toll of the parole board process, the frustration many families experience within the justice system, and what it feels like to repeatedly relive unimaginable loss while fighting to keep a victim’s voice alive. Through grief, resilience, and determination, Hannah offers an honest look at the lifelong impact violent crime leaves on surviving families.

This episode continues our exploration into the Krystle Cook case and the people carrying her legacy forward in the pursuit of justice, awareness, and change.


Music License - HUN48UZPYPFFFR0R

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19159495 Fri, 22 May 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2301 Krystle Cook, Hannah Mosbrucker, true crime podcast, victims rights, parole board, justice system, family tragedy, violent crime, nonprofit advocacy, victim advocacy, unsolved crime, criminal justice reform, grief and loss, surviving family, parole hearin 2 23 full false S2E22 - Krystle Cook: A Father’s Fight for Justice - Part 2 S2E22 - Krystle Cook: A Father’s Fight for Justice - Part 2 In Part 2 of the Krystle Cook story, we continue our powerful conversation with Lee Cook, Krystle’s father, as he shares the ongoing realities of navigating grief, the legal system, and the long road toward justice. Lee opens up about the emotional and financial toll families often face after tragedy, the frustrations and limitations within the court process, and how those experiences pushed his family to take action beyond their own case.

We also explore how their non-profit organization evolved into a source of support, advocacy, and guidance for other families facing similar heartbreak. Through compassion, hard-earned experience, and determination, Lee explains how they are working to ensure others do not have to walk this road alone.

This episode is a raw and honest look at loss, resilience, advocacy, and the lasting impact one family can have in helping others find hope during unimaginable circumstances.


Music License - JR2QXNFWXEVTOV1Z, KZYGROMDUHN8OCKE

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In Part 2 of the Krystle Cook story, we continue our powerful conversation with Lee Cook, Krystle’s father, as he shares the ongoing realities of navigating grief, the legal system, and the long road toward justice. Lee opens up about the emotional and financial toll families often face after tragedy, the frustrations and limitations within the court process, and how those experiences pushed his family to take action beyond their own case.

We also explore how their non-profit organization evolved into a source of support, advocacy, and guidance for other families facing similar heartbreak. Through compassion, hard-earned experience, and determination, Lee explains how they are working to ensure others do not have to walk this road alone.

This episode is a raw and honest look at loss, resilience, advocacy, and the lasting impact one family can have in helping others find hope during unimaginable circumstances.


Music License - JR2QXNFWXEVTOV1Z, KZYGROMDUHN8OCKE

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19148054 Fri, 15 May 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1658 true crime, Krystle Cook, Lee Cook, justice for Krystle, victim advocacy, criminal justice system, grief and loss, family advocacy, nonprofit organization, wrongful death, legal system, tragedy podcast, victim support, advocacy work, unsolved cases, crime 2 22 full false S2E21 - Krystle Cook: A Father’s Fight for Justice – Part 1 S2E21 - Krystle Cook: A Father’s Fight for Justice – Part 1 In this powerful introduction to our series on the case of Krystle Cook, we begin examining the heartbreaking realities surrounding her story — the challenges of victim advocacy, the frustrations families often face within the legal system, and the lasting emotional toll left behind after tragedy.

We also begin our two-part interview with Krystle’s father, as he shares his firsthand experience navigating grief, unanswered questions, and his relentless pursuit of justice for his daughter. Lee opens up about the pain his family has endured, the obstacles they have encountered, and the determination that continues to drive him forward.

This episode sets the stage for a deeply emotional and important series focused not only on Krystle’s case, but also on the broader struggles families face when seeking accountability and support after unimaginable loss.


Music License - ZUGAP5HNLM6LQJDL, FFJE125AKXBWIIAA

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this powerful introduction to our series on the case of Krystle Cook, we begin examining the heartbreaking realities surrounding her story — the challenges of victim advocacy, the frustrations families often face within the legal system, and the lasting emotional toll left behind after tragedy.

We also begin our two-part interview with Krystle’s father, as he shares his firsthand experience navigating grief, unanswered questions, and his relentless pursuit of justice for his daughter. Lee opens up about the pain his family has endured, the obstacles they have encountered, and the determination that continues to drive him forward.

This episode sets the stage for a deeply emotional and important series focused not only on Krystle’s case, but also on the broader struggles families face when seeking accountability and support after unimaginable loss.


Music License - ZUGAP5HNLM6LQJDL, FFJE125AKXBWIIAA

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19143901 Fri, 08 May 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1970 Krystle Cook, Lee Cook, true crime, justice for Krystle Cook, victim advocacy, criminal justice system, unsolved cases, family interview, cold case, grief and loss, victims rights, legal system failures, investigative podcast, true crime podcast 2 21 full false S2E20 - A Mother’s Voice: Thomasene Butler and the Fight for LaTonya S2E20 - A Mother’s Voice: Thomasene Butler and the Fight for LaTonya For years, LaTonya Thomas’s story has gone largely unheard. In this episode, we speak with her mother, Thomasene Butler, as she shares intimate details about her daughter’s life, the events surrounding the day she died, and the lasting emotional toll.

We also explore new updates in the case, including possible law enforcement involvement and growing efforts to bring long-overdue media attention to LaTonya’s story. Thomasene’s voice adds powerful context to a case that continues to raise questions.

This episode is based on available information, including interviews and public records, and is intended for informational purposes only. Any individual discussed in this case is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.


Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> For years, LaTonya Thomas’s story has gone largely unheard. In this episode, we speak with her mother, Thomasene Butler, as she shares intimate details about her daughter’s life, the events surrounding the day she died, and the lasting emotional toll.

We also explore new updates in the case, including possible law enforcement involvement and growing efforts to bring long-overdue media attention to LaTonya’s story. Thomasene’s voice adds powerful context to a case that continues to raise questions.

This episode is based on available information, including interviews and public records, and is intended for informational purposes only. Any individual discussed in this case is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.


Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19109078 Fri, 01 May 2026 11:00:00 -0400 1665 LaTonya Thomas, Thomasene Butler, true crime, true crime podcast, unsolved case, cold case, justice for LaTonya, victim advocacy, family interview, grieving mother, crime investigation, law enforcement, case update, new evidence, media attention, overlook 2 20 full false S2E19 - She Deserves the Truth: Vicki Jenkins Speaks on LaTonya Thomas S2E19 - She Deserves the Truth: Vicki Jenkins Speaks on LaTonya Thomas In this powerful interview, we sit down with Vicki Jenkins to uncover the woman behind the case. Vicki shares deeply personal stories of who LaTonya was, the days leading up to her death, and what she understands about the day everything changed.

Through firsthand accounts and lived experience, this episode sheds light on unanswered questions and the lasting impact LaTonya’s death has had on those who loved her.

Vicki also makes a direct and emotional plea to law enforcement: reopen the case and take another look.

This is not just a story about loss—it’s a call for accountability, transparency, and justice.

Any individual discussed in this case is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Music License - GHJZKCXBNTW6DOBJ

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this powerful interview, we sit down with Vicki Jenkins to uncover the woman behind the case. Vicki shares deeply personal stories of who LaTonya was, the days leading up to her death, and what she understands about the day everything changed.

Through firsthand accounts and lived experience, this episode sheds light on unanswered questions and the lasting impact LaTonya’s death has had on those who loved her.

Vicki also makes a direct and emotional plea to law enforcement: reopen the case and take another look.

This is not just a story about loss—it’s a call for accountability, transparency, and justice.

Any individual discussed in this case is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Music License - GHJZKCXBNTW6DOBJ

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19055320 Fri, 24 Apr 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1241 LaTonya Thomas, Vicki Jenkins, true crime, unsolved case, cold case, wrongful closure, reopen the case, justice for LaTonya Thomas, victim advocacy, criminal investigation, law enforcement accountability, suspicious death, case review, eyewitness account, 2 19 full false S2E18 - The Last Days of LaTonya: Crystal Newkirk Speaks S2E18 - The Last Days of LaTonya: Crystal Newkirk Speaks In this deeply personal episode, we sit down with Crystal Newkirk—one of LaTonya’s closest friends—to hear a firsthand account of the days leading up to LaTonya’s death, the day everything changed, and the lasting impact left behind.

Crystal shares intimate details about LaTonya as a person—the friend she was, the life she lived, and the moments that now carry new weight in hindsight. Through her voice, we gain a clearer picture of what those final days looked like and the questions that still remain.

This conversation is more than a retelling of events—it’s a reflection on loss, unanswered questions, and the enduring ripple effect of a life taken too soon.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - GUADJH3ACJJFVSCB, AHUUGTWUJOZNGFES

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this deeply personal episode, we sit down with Crystal Newkirk—one of LaTonya’s closest friends—to hear a firsthand account of the days leading up to LaTonya’s death, the day everything changed, and the lasting impact left behind.

Crystal shares intimate details about LaTonya as a person—the friend she was, the life she lived, and the moments that now carry new weight in hindsight. Through her voice, we gain a clearer picture of what those final days looked like and the questions that still remain.

This conversation is more than a retelling of events—it’s a reflection on loss, unanswered questions, and the enduring ripple effect of a life taken too soon.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - GUADJH3ACJJFVSCB, AHUUGTWUJOZNGFES

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-19011055 Fri, 17 Apr 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1170 LaTonya Thomas, Crystal Newkirk, true crime podcast, unsolved case, underserved victims, wrongful closure, victim advocacy, missing justice, firsthand account, FOIA investigation, cold case, crime story, justice system failure, victim impact, real crime s 2 18 full false S2E17 - LaTonya Thomas: A Case Closed Too Soon S2E17 - LaTonya Thomas: A Case Closed Too Soon LaTonya Thomas’s case is one that truly defines what it means to be underserved—and overlooked.

In this episode, we break down the facts uncovered through our FOIA request, examining the official records, timelines, and key details that paint a troubling picture. What we found raises serious questions about how this case was handled and why it was closed when so much remains unresolved.

We walk through what is known today, highlight gaps in the investigation, and discuss the lasting impact on LaTonya’s family—who are still searching for answers and justice.

This is more than a case review. It’s a call to look deeper at the systems that fail victims and families when they need support the most.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - 21IGJYYM19CTIBA0, PKKOFKDRYA26F3HA

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> LaTonya Thomas’s case is one that truly defines what it means to be underserved—and overlooked.

In this episode, we break down the facts uncovered through our FOIA request, examining the official records, timelines, and key details that paint a troubling picture. What we found raises serious questions about how this case was handled and why it was closed when so much remains unresolved.

We walk through what is known today, highlight gaps in the investigation, and discuss the lasting impact on LaTonya’s family—who are still searching for answers and justice.

This is more than a case review. It’s a call to look deeper at the systems that fail victims and families when they need support the most.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - 21IGJYYM19CTIBA0, PKKOFKDRYA26F3HA

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18998697 Sat, 11 Apr 2026 13:00:00 -0400 1424 LaTonya Thomas, true crime podcast, unsolved cases, cold case, FOIA records, wrongful case closure, justice for victims, underserved communities, investigative breakdown, missing justice, case analysis, police investigation, victim advocacy, family impact 2 17 full false S2E16 - The Friend Who Stayed: Amanda Rowton on Hailey Athay, Family, and the Life Left Behind S2E16 - The Friend Who Stayed: Amanda Rowton on Hailey Athay, Family, and the Life Left Behind In this episode, we sit down with Amanda Rowton, one of Hailey Athay’s closest friends, for a deeply personal and emotional conversation about who Hailey really is beyond the headlines.

Amanda shares what it was like to know Hailey as a friend—the kind of person she was, the memories they built together, and the bond they shared. But this story doesn’t stop at loss. It’s about what comes after.

Amanda opens up about the responsibility and love involved in helping care for one of Hailey’s children, and how this unimaginable situation has reshaped her life and the lives of those around her. Through grief, resilience, and unwavering loyalty, she offers a perspective rarely heard in missing person cases—the voice of the friend who steps in and never steps away.

This is a story about friendship, family, and the lasting impact of disappearance.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - VA2CCGYWY0SPWZNF

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we sit down with Amanda Rowton, one of Hailey Athay’s closest friends, for a deeply personal and emotional conversation about who Hailey really is beyond the headlines.

Amanda shares what it was like to know Hailey as a friend—the kind of person she was, the memories they built together, and the bond they shared. But this story doesn’t stop at loss. It’s about what comes after.

Amanda opens up about the responsibility and love involved in helping care for one of Hailey’s children, and how this unimaginable situation has reshaped her life and the lives of those around her. Through grief, resilience, and unwavering loyalty, she offers a perspective rarely heard in missing person cases—the voice of the friend who steps in and never steps away.

This is a story about friendship, family, and the lasting impact of disappearance.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - VA2CCGYWY0SPWZNF

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18938572 Fri, 03 Apr 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1903 Hailey Athay, Amanda Rowton, missing person, true crime podcast, unresolved cases, family impact, grief, victim advocacy, cold case, disappearance, community support, raising a child, friendship, trauma, resilience, Tragedy podcast 2 16 full false S2E15 - Sister, Mother, Advocate: Ashley Griggs on Life After Hailey’s Disappearance S2E15 - Sister, Mother, Advocate: Ashley Griggs on Life After Hailey’s Disappearance Ashley Griggs joins us to discuss the disappearance of her sister, Hailey Athay, and the details she believes matter most. From her perspective on the events of that day to the lingering questions that continue to haunt the case, Ashley provides a candid and emotional account. She also shares what it means to raise Hailey’s daughter in the absence of answers—and how that responsibility fuels her pursuit of truth. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - H33GR4U7UMVRCLQL

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Ashley Griggs joins us to discuss the disappearance of her sister, Hailey Athay, and the details she believes matter most. From her perspective on the events of that day to the lingering questions that continue to haunt the case, Ashley provides a candid and emotional account. She also shares what it means to raise Hailey’s daughter in the absence of answers—and how that responsibility fuels her pursuit of truth. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - H33GR4U7UMVRCLQL

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18922015 Mon, 30 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2202 true crime, Hailey Athay, Ashley Griggs, missing person, unsolved case, cold case, family interview, disappearance, advocacy, grief, justice, raising her daughter, survivor story, real crime, true crime podcast 2 15 full false S2E14 - BONUS! - The Hidden Weight of Every Case: Understanding Grief S2E14 - BONUS! - The Hidden Weight of Every Case: Understanding Grief Behind every missing persons case is something we don’t always talk about enough—grief.

In this episode, we speak with Nick Gaylord, host of Grief Is Not a Dirty Word, about why grief deserves a louder voice and how his podcast is helping break the stigma around it. He shares his journey into podcasting, what drives his mission, and why these conversations matter.

We also explore how grief impacts families, communities, and even those telling these stories. Because at the heart of every case we cover… there are people carrying unimaginable weight.


Music License - FYMFDYSEEX8RQAY8

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Behind every missing persons case is something we don’t always talk about enough—grief.

In this episode, we speak with Nick Gaylord, host of Grief Is Not a Dirty Word, about why grief deserves a louder voice and how his podcast is helping break the stigma around it. He shares his journey into podcasting, what drives his mission, and why these conversations matter.

We also explore how grief impacts families, communities, and even those telling these stories. Because at the heart of every case we cover… there are people carrying unimaginable weight.


Music License - FYMFDYSEEX8RQAY8

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Buzzsprout-18896806 Fri, 27 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0400 3751 true crime, true crime podcast, missing persons, grief, trauma, Nick Gaylord, grief is not a dirty word, victim advocacy, emotional impact, storytelling, unresolved cases, loss, healing, podcast interview, tragedy podcast 2 14 full false S2E13 - She Won’t Stop Looking: Nicole Brooks on Hailey Athay S2E13 - She Won’t Stop Looking: Nicole Brooks on Hailey Athay When someone goes missing, the world moves on—but families don’t.

In this episode, we speak with Nicole Brooks, the mother of Hailey Athay, who shares the reality of living in the unknown. Nicole walks us through the details she knows, the questions that still linger, and how Hailey’s disappearance has changed her life forever.

We also explore the importance of community support and advocacy in keeping cases like Hailey’s alive. This is a raw and powerful conversation about grief, strength, and a mother’s determination to find answers.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - RLPXBMPF8JNDDLQ7

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> When someone goes missing, the world moves on—but families don’t.

In this episode, we speak with Nicole Brooks, the mother of Hailey Athay, who shares the reality of living in the unknown. Nicole walks us through the details she knows, the questions that still linger, and how Hailey’s disappearance has changed her life forever.

We also explore the importance of community support and advocacy in keeping cases like Hailey’s alive. This is a raw and powerful conversation about grief, strength, and a mother’s determination to find answers.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - RLPXBMPF8JNDDLQ7

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18887944 Mon, 23 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0400 2637 Hailey Athay, Nicole Brooks, missing person, missing persons case, true crime, true crime podcast, unsolved case, unsolved mystery, disappearance, cold case, family interview, victim advocacy, missing persons advocacy 2 13 full false S2E12 - Celebrating Episode 50: Inside the Mind of an FBI Profiler with Julia Cowley S2E12 - Celebrating Episode 50: Inside the Mind of an FBI Profiler with Julia Cowley For our 50th episode milestone, we sit down with Julia Cowley, a former profiler from the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Behavioral Analysis Unit and host of the podcast The Consult.

In this conversation, we reflect on our first experience meeting Julia and how her philosophy and approach to investigative work helped shape the focus and mission behind our own podcast. Julia shares insights from her time working inside the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit, discussing how profilers analyze behavior, develop offender profiles, and approach complex cases.

We also explore the human side of investigations—Julia’s perspective on working with families of the missing and murdered, the importance of empathy in investigative work, and how responsible true-crime platforms can help raise awareness, encourage community engagement, and potentially move cases forward.

This episode is both a look back at our journey to episode 50 and a powerful conversation about behavioral analysis, advocacy, and the role media can play in seeking answers.

Music License - N2YGW3W4KNAWPMRN

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> For our 50th episode milestone, we sit down with Julia Cowley, a former profiler from the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Behavioral Analysis Unit and host of the podcast The Consult.

In this conversation, we reflect on our first experience meeting Julia and how her philosophy and approach to investigative work helped shape the focus and mission behind our own podcast. Julia shares insights from her time working inside the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit, discussing how profilers analyze behavior, develop offender profiles, and approach complex cases.

We also explore the human side of investigations—Julia’s perspective on working with families of the missing and murdered, the importance of empathy in investigative work, and how responsible true-crime platforms can help raise awareness, encourage community engagement, and potentially move cases forward.

This episode is both a look back at our journey to episode 50 and a powerful conversation about behavioral analysis, advocacy, and the role media can play in seeking answers.

Music License - N2YGW3W4KNAWPMRN

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18822725 Mon, 16 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0400 3202 true crime, Julia Cowley, FBI profiler, Behavioral Analysis Unit, BAU, FBI behavioral analysis, criminal profiling, cold cases, missing persons, unsolved cases, investigative psychology, case analysis, true crime podcast, The Consult podcast 2 12 full false S2E11 - Still Searching for Hailey Athay: Shasta Ives Speaks S2E11 - Still Searching for Hailey Athay: Shasta Ives Speaks In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we speak with Shasta Ives, a close friend of Hailey Athay and a passionate advocate in the ongoing search for answers surrounding Hailey’s disappearance.

Hailey vanished while mushroom picking in Washington, and despite search efforts and years of unanswered questions, those closest to her have never stopped looking for the truth.

Shasta shares what Hailey was like as a person and the friendship they shared. She also gives a firsthand account of the search efforts, describing the terrain, the volunteers who came together to help, and the determination of those who refuse to let Hailey’s case fade into the background.

But this conversation goes beyond the search itself. Shasta opens up about how Hailey’s disappearance has deeply affected her life and why she continues to advocate for attention and answers in Hailey’s case.

Behind every missing person case is a community still searching, still hoping, and still fighting for justice.

If you have information regarding the disappearance of Hailey Athay, please contact local law enforcement.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - JRKZ7XR86OGECJBI

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, we speak with Shasta Ives, a close friend of Hailey Athay and a passionate advocate in the ongoing search for answers surrounding Hailey’s disappearance.

Hailey vanished while mushroom picking in Washington, and despite search efforts and years of unanswered questions, those closest to her have never stopped looking for the truth.

Shasta shares what Hailey was like as a person and the friendship they shared. She also gives a firsthand account of the search efforts, describing the terrain, the volunteers who came together to help, and the determination of those who refuse to let Hailey’s case fade into the background.

But this conversation goes beyond the search itself. Shasta opens up about how Hailey’s disappearance has deeply affected her life and why she continues to advocate for attention and answers in Hailey’s case.

Behind every missing person case is a community still searching, still hoping, and still fighting for justice.

If you have information regarding the disappearance of Hailey Athay, please contact local law enforcement.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - JRKZ7XR86OGECJBI

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18813098 Mon, 09 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0400 1892 Hailey Athay, missing person, Washington missing persons, true crime podcast, Shasta Ives, missing persons advocacy, unsolved disappearance, mushroom picking disappearance, wilderness disappearance, search efforts, missing persons awareness 2 11 full false S2E10 - Lost in the Woods: The Disappearance of Hailey Athay S2E10 - Lost in the Woods: The Disappearance of Hailey Athay Hailey Athay went into the woods for a simple day of mushroom picking — and never came home.

In this episode, we break down the known timeline of Hailey’s disappearance, the location where she was last seen, and the search efforts that followed. What should have been an ordinary outing turned into a haunting mystery that still demands answers.

We walk through the facts, the unanswered questions, and the challenges that arise in wilderness disappearances. But this episode is more than a case summary — it’s also about advocacy. We discuss the growing call for increased attention, awareness, and media coverage surrounding Hailey’s case, and why keeping her name in the public conversation matters.

When someone vanishes in the woods, the clock starts ticking. But when public attention fades, families are left fighting for visibility. Tonight, we bring Hailey’s story back into focus.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - DLUP3HNXOB6M4DZK, A0IJ8Y4ULJO6FIWE

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Hailey Athay went into the woods for a simple day of mushroom picking — and never came home.

In this episode, we break down the known timeline of Hailey’s disappearance, the location where she was last seen, and the search efforts that followed. What should have been an ordinary outing turned into a haunting mystery that still demands answers.

We walk through the facts, the unanswered questions, and the challenges that arise in wilderness disappearances. But this episode is more than a case summary — it’s also about advocacy. We discuss the growing call for increased attention, awareness, and media coverage surrounding Hailey’s case, and why keeping her name in the public conversation matters.

When someone vanishes in the woods, the clock starts ticking. But when public attention fades, families are left fighting for visibility. Tonight, we bring Hailey’s story back into focus.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - DLUP3HNXOB6M4DZK, A0IJ8Y4ULJO6FIWE

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18766490 Mon, 02 Mar 2026 08:00:00 -0500 1004 Hailey Athay, missing person, wilderness disappearance, mushroom picking, unsolved case, cold case, true crime podcast, missing in the woods, search efforts, advocacy, awareness, unresolved mystery, investigative discussion 2 10 full false S2E9 - BONUS! - Audrey Herron: Inside the Case — A Cold Case Collective Roundtable S2E9 - BONUS! - Audrey Herron: Inside the Case — A Cold Case Collective Roundtable In this special roundtable episode, we sit down with members of the Cold Case Collective to take a deep, collaborative look at the disappearance of Audrey Herron. Together, we walk through the known timeline, key details of the case, and the evidence that has shaped the investigation over the years.

This conversation explores the many theories surrounding Audrey’s disappearance, from the most widely discussed possibilities to the questions that still linger without answers. We also examine the unique challenges investigators face in long-term missing person cases—aging evidence, shifting leads, limited resources, and the emotional toll on families and communities.

Through thoughtful discussion and shared expertise, this roundtable highlights why Audrey’s case still matters and what it takes to keep cold cases alive in the pursuit of truth and justice.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - P3CDNEWUOV1NTDG6

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this special roundtable episode, we sit down with members of the Cold Case Collective to take a deep, collaborative look at the disappearance of Audrey Herron. Together, we walk through the known timeline, key details of the case, and the evidence that has shaped the investigation over the years.

This conversation explores the many theories surrounding Audrey’s disappearance, from the most widely discussed possibilities to the questions that still linger without answers. We also examine the unique challenges investigators face in long-term missing person cases—aging evidence, shifting leads, limited resources, and the emotional toll on families and communities.

Through thoughtful discussion and shared expertise, this roundtable highlights why Audrey’s case still matters and what it takes to keep cold cases alive in the pursuit of truth and justice.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Music License - P3CDNEWUOV1NTDG6

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18757978 Fri, 27 Feb 2026 08:00:00 -0500 4230 Audrey Herron, cold case, missing person, unsolved disappearance, Cold Case Collective, true crime podcast, cold case investigation, unsolved mystery, missing persons advocacy, investigative discussion, case theories, forensic challenges, law enforcement, 2 9 full false S2E8 - She Was More Than a Headline: Mitzie Wilson Remembers Audrey Herron S2E8 - She Was More Than a Headline: Mitzie Wilson Remembers Audrey Herron In this deeply personal episode, we speak with Mitzie Wilson, one of Audrey Herron’s closest friends. Mitzie takes us back to the days when Audrey wasn’t a missing person case — she was a mother, a friend, a presence in the room.

Mitzie shares intimate memories of their time together, what made Audrey unique, and the moments that now carry a different weight in hindsight. We discuss Audrey’s disappearance, the shock that rippled through their community, Mitzie’s personal theories about what may have happened, and the lasting emotional impact of those first days without answers.

This conversation is raw, reflective, and a powerful reminder that behind every missing person case is a life deeply woven into others.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 3PZ2YTCDTRGAS5UO

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this deeply personal episode, we speak with Mitzie Wilson, one of Audrey Herron’s closest friends. Mitzie takes us back to the days when Audrey wasn’t a missing person case — she was a mother, a friend, a presence in the room.

Mitzie shares intimate memories of their time together, what made Audrey unique, and the moments that now carry a different weight in hindsight. We discuss Audrey’s disappearance, the shock that rippled through their community, Mitzie’s personal theories about what may have happened, and the lasting emotional impact of those first days without answers.

This conversation is raw, reflective, and a powerful reminder that behind every missing person case is a life deeply woven into others.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 3PZ2YTCDTRGAS5UO

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18725904 Mon, 23 Feb 2026 08:00:00 -0500 2486 Audrey Herron, Mitzie Wilson, missing person, unsolved case, true crime podcast, cold case, disappearance, Glens Falls NY, Upstate New York, friends perspective, personal memories, victim impact, community impact, search efforts, unsolved mystery, investi 2 8 full false S2E7 - Five Minutes, Five Cases: Urgent Updates & A Conversation with Audrey Herron’s Stepmother S2E7 - Five Minutes, Five Cases: Urgent Updates & A Conversation with Audrey Herron’s Stepmother In this special short-format update, we bring you a focused five-minute briefing on several cases that continue to weigh heavily on families and communities: Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Cody Haney, Johnathan Hagans, and Michael John Olson. We share the latest developments, where each case stands today, and what listeners need to know right now.

We are also joined by Jeanne Turk, stepmother of Audrey Herron and the person who reported her missing. Jeanne reflects on the earliest moments of Audrey’s disappearance, the emotional toll of the search, and the years spent fighting to keep Audrey’s story alive. Her perspective offers a powerful reminder that behind every case is a family still searching for answers.

These updates may be brief—but the stories, the impact, and the hope for resolution remain as strong as ever.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - A0SJD70RWISAZU05

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this special short-format update, we bring you a focused five-minute briefing on several cases that continue to weigh heavily on families and communities: Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Cody Haney, Johnathan Hagans, and Michael John Olson. We share the latest developments, where each case stands today, and what listeners need to know right now.

We are also joined by Jeanne Turk, stepmother of Audrey Herron and the person who reported her missing. Jeanne reflects on the earliest moments of Audrey’s disappearance, the emotional toll of the search, and the years spent fighting to keep Audrey’s story alive. Her perspective offers a powerful reminder that behind every case is a family still searching for answers.

These updates may be brief—but the stories, the impact, and the hope for resolution remain as strong as ever.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - A0SJD70RWISAZU05

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18688463 Mon, 16 Feb 2026 08:00:00 -0500 3387 true crime, missing persons, cold cases, unsolved cases, case updates, Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Cody Haney, Johnathan Hagans, Michael John Olsen, Audrey Herron, Jeanne Turk, family of the missing, ongoing investigations, justice for the missing, awarenes 2 7 full false S2E6 - The Daughter Left Behind: Sonsia Elliot Remembers Audrey Herron S2E6 - The Daughter Left Behind: Sonsia Elliot Remembers Audrey Herron Sonsia Elliot, the oldest daughter of missing mother Audrey Herron, joins us to share her firsthand memories of the days before her mother vanished. She recounts the early searches, the hope, the confusion, and the heartbreak that followed. Beyond the case itself, Sonsia reflects on the lasting emotional toll of her mother’s disappearance and what it means to grow up with unanswered questions. Her story adds a crucial and human perspective to a case that continues to haunt so many.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 4QXYHRASFJGGDIQX

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Sonsia Elliot, the oldest daughter of missing mother Audrey Herron, joins us to share her firsthand memories of the days before her mother vanished. She recounts the early searches, the hope, the confusion, and the heartbreak that followed. Beyond the case itself, Sonsia reflects on the lasting emotional toll of her mother’s disappearance and what it means to grow up with unanswered questions. Her story adds a crucial and human perspective to a case that continues to haunt so many.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 4QXYHRASFJGGDIQX

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18602708 Mon, 09 Feb 2026 08:00:00 -0500 1564 Audrey Herron, Sonsia Elliot, missing persons, unresolved disappearance, true crime podcast, cold case, family perspective, victim’s family, grief without closure, unsolved mystery, search and rescue, missing mothers, personal impact of crime, survivor st 2 6 full false S2E5 - Living With the Memory: Corrina Dedrick’s Emotional Reflection on the Audrey Herron Case S2E5 - Living With the Memory: Corrina Dedrick’s Emotional Reflection on the Audrey Herron Case In this deeply emotional episode, we sit down with Corrina Dedrick as she shares her personal memories of the case and the lasting impact it has had on her life. Corrina speaks openly about the weight of carrying these memories, the emotions that still surface years later, and how the experience shaped who she is today.

This conversation is raw, vulnerable, and honest—offering listeners a rare look at how unresolved cases don’t just affect headlines and timelines, but real people who continue to live with the echoes of what happened. Corrina’s courage in sharing her story reminds us that behind every case are lives forever changed.

Listener discretion advised: This episode contains emotional discussions that may be difficult for some listeners.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 7GMCFJDDXHEZ9PQL

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this deeply emotional episode, we sit down with Corrina Dedrick as she shares her personal memories of the case and the lasting impact it has had on her life. Corrina speaks openly about the weight of carrying these memories, the emotions that still surface years later, and how the experience shaped who she is today.

This conversation is raw, vulnerable, and honest—offering listeners a rare look at how unresolved cases don’t just affect headlines and timelines, but real people who continue to live with the echoes of what happened. Corrina’s courage in sharing her story reminds us that behind every case are lives forever changed.

Listener discretion advised: This episode contains emotional discussions that may be difficult for some listeners.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 7GMCFJDDXHEZ9PQL

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18564494 Mon, 02 Feb 2026 08:00:00 -0500 2962 True Crime, True Crime Podcast, Victim Voices, Personal Impact, Emotional Interview, Unsolved Cases, Missing Persons, Trauma Awareness, Lived Experience, Advocacy, Healing, Never Forgotten, True Crime Community 2 5 full false S2E4 - Adventures with Purpose: Bill McIntosh and the Human Cost of Missing Persons S2E4 - Adventures with Purpose: Bill McIntosh and the Human Cost of Missing Persons In this powerful and deeply human conversation, we sit down with Bill McIntosh from Adventures With Purpose to discuss the tireless work being done to help families find answers when a loved one goes missing.

Bill shares his personal journey into this work, what drives him to continue showing up case after case, and how purpose — not fame or recognition — fuels every search. We dive into the efforts made during the Audrey Herron case, exploring what went into the search, the challenges faced, and the emotional weight carried by those working behind the scenes.

Beyond a single case, Bill opens up about the broader mission of Adventures With Purpose, the impact their work has on families and communities, and how recovery — even when outcomes are heartbreaking — can bring clarity, dignity, and a form of healing to those left waiting.

This episode is about more than investigations. It’s about compassion, commitment, and the people who refuse to let the missing be forgotten.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - WBIQCEVOVAAPZSGV

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this powerful and deeply human conversation, we sit down with Bill McIntosh from Adventures With Purpose to discuss the tireless work being done to help families find answers when a loved one goes missing.

Bill shares his personal journey into this work, what drives him to continue showing up case after case, and how purpose — not fame or recognition — fuels every search. We dive into the efforts made during the Audrey Herron case, exploring what went into the search, the challenges faced, and the emotional weight carried by those working behind the scenes.

Beyond a single case, Bill opens up about the broader mission of Adventures With Purpose, the impact their work has on families and communities, and how recovery — even when outcomes are heartbreaking — can bring clarity, dignity, and a form of healing to those left waiting.

This episode is about more than investigations. It’s about compassion, commitment, and the people who refuse to let the missing be forgotten.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - WBIQCEVOVAAPZSGV

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18549486 Mon, 26 Jan 2026 08:00:00 -0500 2668 AdventureWithPurpose, DiveTeam, SearchAndRecovery, ColdCaseSupport, UnsolvedCases 2 4 full false S2E3 - A Friend’s Promise: Marie Parker on the Search for Audrey May Herron S2E3 - A Friend’s Promise: Marie Parker on the Search for Audrey May Herron In this episode, we sit down with Marie Parker, a close friend of Audrey May Herron, whose unwavering dedication has helped keep Audrey’s story alive when it might otherwise have faded from public attention.

For years, Marie has spent hundreds of hours reviewing records, retracing timelines, speaking with sources, and examining every available detail surrounding Audrey’s disappearance. Not as a professional investigator, but as a friend who refuses to give up.

Marie shares who Audrey was beyond the headlines, what first compelled her to begin investigating, and why she continues pushing forward with one clear goal: to help bring Audrey home. This conversation is not about rumors or accusations, it’s about persistence, love, and the quiet work of advocacy that often happens behind the scenes.

If you believe cold cases still matter, and that remembering a name can be an act of justice, this is a conversation you won’t want to miss.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 5YDIRGON66HFJQWZ

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we sit down with Marie Parker, a close friend of Audrey May Herron, whose unwavering dedication has helped keep Audrey’s story alive when it might otherwise have faded from public attention.

For years, Marie has spent hundreds of hours reviewing records, retracing timelines, speaking with sources, and examining every available detail surrounding Audrey’s disappearance. Not as a professional investigator, but as a friend who refuses to give up.

Marie shares who Audrey was beyond the headlines, what first compelled her to begin investigating, and why she continues pushing forward with one clear goal: to help bring Audrey home. This conversation is not about rumors or accusations, it’s about persistence, love, and the quiet work of advocacy that often happens behind the scenes.

If you believe cold cases still matter, and that remembering a name can be an act of justice, this is a conversation you won’t want to miss.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Music License - 5YDIRGON66HFJQWZ

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18498172 Mon, 19 Jan 2026 08:00:00 -0500 2557 Audrey May Herron, Marie Parker, Missing Person, New York 2 3 full false S2E2 - Remembering Audrey May Herron: Maria Hadley on Friendship, Advocacy, and the Search for Answers S2E2 - Remembering Audrey May Herron: Maria Hadley on Friendship, Advocacy, and the Search for Answers In this episode, we speak with Maria Hadley, a close friend of Audrey May Herron and a passionate advocate who worked tirelessly to keep Audrey’s name, story, and search alive.

Maria shares what Audrey was like as a person, how their friendship began, and the moments that still stand out years later. She also reflects on the challenges, frustrations, and emotional toll of advocating for answers in a case that has left so many questions unresolved.

This conversation is not about speculation or accusation, it’s about memory, perseverance, and the human impact of a disappearance that continues to matter. Through Maria’s voice, we honor Audrey and the people who refused to let her be forgotten.

If you know anything. Please contact the NY State Police - (518) 622-8600

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we speak with Maria Hadley, a close friend of Audrey May Herron and a passionate advocate who worked tirelessly to keep Audrey’s name, story, and search alive.

Maria shares what Audrey was like as a person, how their friendship began, and the moments that still stand out years later. She also reflects on the challenges, frustrations, and emotional toll of advocating for answers in a case that has left so many questions unresolved.

This conversation is not about speculation or accusation, it’s about memory, perseverance, and the human impact of a disappearance that continues to matter. Through Maria’s voice, we honor Audrey and the people who refused to let her be forgotten.

If you know anything. Please contact the NY State Police - (518) 622-8600

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18490774 Mon, 12 Jan 2026 08:00:00 -0500 3350 Audrey May Herron, NY, Missing Person 2 2 full true S2E1 - Season 2 Premiere: The Disappearance of Audrey May Herron S2E1 - Season 2 Premiere: The Disappearance of Audrey May Herron Season 2 begins with a careful review of the disappearance of Audrey May Herron. In this episode, we walk through the known facts of the case, the timeline of events, and the publicly available information surrounding her disappearance. As the first case of the new year, this episode sets the tone for the season, focusing on verified details, unanswered questions, and the importance of keeping missing persons cases in the public eye. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Season 2 begins with a careful review of the disappearance of Audrey May Herron. In this episode, we walk through the known facts of the case, the timeline of events, and the publicly available information surrounding her disappearance. As the first case of the new year, this episode sets the tone for the season, focusing on verified details, unanswered questions, and the importance of keeping missing persons cases in the public eye. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18449464 Mon, 05 Jan 2026 08:00:00 -0500 1510 Audrey Herron, Missing Person, New York 2 1 full false S1E38 - BONUS! Not Forgotten: A Christmas Update on the Ian Rogers Case S1E38 - BONUS! Not Forgotten: A Christmas Update on the Ian Rogers Case In this Christmas bonus episode, we provide an update on the Ian Rogers case, including discussion of images related to a truck that has been part of public conversation. We explain how those images were located, what can reasonably be understood from them, and where uncertainty remains.

We also address questions surrounding law enforcement actions and communication, while being clear about what is known, what is unconfirmed, and what remains unanswered. This episode is intended to inform, not speculate, and to encourage thoughtful discussion.

As always, we close by thanking the community for their continued engagement, tips, and respectful dialogue. Especially during the holidays, we recognize the importance of keeping these conversations grounded, responsible, and human.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this Christmas bonus episode, we provide an update on the Ian Rogers case, including discussion of images related to a truck that has been part of public conversation. We explain how those images were located, what can reasonably be understood from them, and where uncertainty remains.

We also address questions surrounding law enforcement actions and communication, while being clear about what is known, what is unconfirmed, and what remains unanswered. This episode is intended to inform, not speculate, and to encourage thoughtful discussion.

As always, we close by thanking the community for their continued engagement, tips, and respectful dialogue. Especially during the holidays, we recognize the importance of keeping these conversations grounded, responsible, and human.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18414760 Thu, 25 Dec 2025 17:00:00 -0500 1275 Ian Rogers, Missing Person, Truck Located 1 38 full false S1E37 - Remembering Cody Haney: Kaci & Chad’s Account of the Weekend That Changed Everything S1E37 - Remembering Cody Haney: Kaci & Chad’s Account of the Weekend That Changed Everything In this episode, we speak with Kaci and Chad, two close friends of Cody, with Chad also having worked alongside him. Through their personal memories and firsthand experiences, they reflect on who Cody was as a person, the relationships he valued, and the impact his disappearance has had on those who knew him best.

They share their recollections of the weekend Cody went missing, discussing the timeline as they remember it, the moments that stood out to them at the time, and the questions that arose in the days that followed. Their conversation focuses on what they personally observed, heard, and experienced, offering listeners additional context surrounding that period.

Kaci and Chad also discuss their own perspectives and opinions regarding aspects of the case that remain unclear. These views are presented solely as personal interpretations based on their experiences and are not statements of fact or allegations. This episode is intended to provide insight into how Cody’s disappearance has been understood by those closest to him, while acknowledging that the case remains unresolved.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we speak with Kaci and Chad, two close friends of Cody, with Chad also having worked alongside him. Through their personal memories and firsthand experiences, they reflect on who Cody was as a person, the relationships he valued, and the impact his disappearance has had on those who knew him best.

They share their recollections of the weekend Cody went missing, discussing the timeline as they remember it, the moments that stood out to them at the time, and the questions that arose in the days that followed. Their conversation focuses on what they personally observed, heard, and experienced, offering listeners additional context surrounding that period.

Kaci and Chad also discuss their own perspectives and opinions regarding aspects of the case that remain unclear. These views are presented solely as personal interpretations based on their experiences and are not statements of fact or allegations. This episode is intended to provide insight into how Cody’s disappearance has been understood by those closest to him, while acknowledging that the case remains unresolved.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18395399 Mon, 22 Dec 2025 08:00:00 -0500 2591 Codey Haney, Chad and Kaci, Missing Person 1 37 full false S1E36 - Searching for Cody: Selena Jimenez Speaks Out S1E36 - Searching for Cody: Selena Jimenez Speaks Out In this episode, we sit down with Selena Jimenez, someone who knew Cody Haney personally and has refused to let his story fade into silence. Selena shares who Cody was to her, the kind of person he was behind the headlines, and how his disappearance impacted her life.

We also discuss the steps Selena has taken within the community to keep Cody’s name alive, from outreach and awareness efforts to her own independent investigation. As the conversation unfolds, Selena walks us through her theories, the questions that continue to haunt her, and why she believes the public still doesn’t have the full picture.

This is a deeply personal conversation about loyalty, unanswered questions, and the determination to seek truth when official answers fall short.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we sit down with Selena Jimenez, someone who knew Cody Haney personally and has refused to let his story fade into silence. Selena shares who Cody was to her, the kind of person he was behind the headlines, and how his disappearance impacted her life.

We also discuss the steps Selena has taken within the community to keep Cody’s name alive, from outreach and awareness efforts to her own independent investigation. As the conversation unfolds, Selena walks us through her theories, the questions that continue to haunt her, and why she believes the public still doesn’t have the full picture.

This is a deeply personal conversation about loyalty, unanswered questions, and the determination to seek truth when official answers fall short.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18352869 Mon, 15 Dec 2025 08:00:00 -0500 2401 Cody Haney, Liberty County, Selena Jimenez 1 36 full false S1E35 - Cody Haney: A Mother’s Voice S1E35 - Cody Haney: A Mother’s Voice In this second installment of our ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Cody Haney, we sit down with his mother, Michele McRoy, for a deeply personal and emotional conversation. Michele shares her memories of Cody, the details she understands about the case, and the painful impact his absence has had over the past year. Her perspective brings new depth to Cody’s story and highlights the unanswered questions that still haunt those who love him. Join us as we continue to seek clarity, truth, and accountability in Cody’s case. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this second installment of our ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Cody Haney, we sit down with his mother, Michele McRoy, for a deeply personal and emotional conversation. Michele shares her memories of Cody, the details she understands about the case, and the painful impact his absence has had over the past year. Her perspective brings new depth to Cody’s story and highlights the unanswered questions that still haunt those who love him. Join us as we continue to seek clarity, truth, and accountability in Cody’s case. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18314744 Mon, 08 Dec 2025 08:00:00 -0500 2828 Cody Haney, Liberty County, Missing Person 1 35 full false S1E34 - BONUS! Our Working Theory on the Hagans Case S1E34 - BONUS! Our Working Theory on the Hagans Case This special bonus installment begins with brief updates on the Ian Rogers and Michael John Olson cases, but its heart lies in a deeper dive into the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans. For the first time, we lay out our full assessment of what likely unfolded that night, what aligns, what contradicts, and what has been overlooked for more than 50 years. Through environmental analysis, witness recollections, and newly uncovered context, we connect the pieces that shape our current theory. If you’ve followed the Hagans case, this is the episode you’ve been waiting for. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> This special bonus installment begins with brief updates on the Ian Rogers and Michael John Olson cases, but its heart lies in a deeper dive into the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans. For the first time, we lay out our full assessment of what likely unfolded that night, what aligns, what contradicts, and what has been overlooked for more than 50 years. Through environmental analysis, witness recollections, and newly uncovered context, we connect the pieces that shape our current theory. If you’ve followed the Hagans case, this is the episode you’ve been waiting for. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18305307 Fri, 05 Dec 2025 10:00:00 -0500 1084 Jonathan Hagans, Jacksonville Beach, Missing Person 1 34 full true S1E33 - Piecing Together What Happened to Cody Haney S1E33 - Piecing Together What Happened to Cody Haney Cody Haney’s story is striking not only for the unanswered questions, but for the overwhelming silence surrounding it. In this case summary, we dig into the scarce details we’ve uncovered, the near-total lack of media reporting, and the challenges of investigating a case with so little public record. We also focus on Cody himself, his personality, his life, and the human being behind the headline that never came. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Cody Haney’s story is striking not only for the unanswered questions, but for the overwhelming silence surrounding it. In this case summary, we dig into the scarce details we’ve uncovered, the near-total lack of media reporting, and the challenges of investigating a case with so little public record. We also focus on Cody himself, his personality, his life, and the human being behind the headline that never came. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18269288 Mon, 01 Dec 2025 07:00:00 -0500 1250 Cody Haney, Liberty County 1 33 full false S1E32 - New Evidence Unearthed: Ian Rogers Update & The Hagans Case Files S1E32 - New Evidence Unearthed: Ian Rogers Update & The Hagans Case Files Today, we bring you critical new developments in two deeply troubling cases. We walk through the latest updates in the Ian Rogers case, including the discovery of his missing truck and the circumstances surrounding where and how it was found. We also break down newly obtained FOIA records from the Jacksonville Beach Police Department related to the case of Jonathan Hagans, documents that shed new light on law enforcement activity, timelines, and unanswered questions that remain over 50 years later.

This episode focuses on facts, records, and newly uncovered information,  separating speculation from verified detail as we continue the pursuit of truth, accountability, and awareness for the victims and their families.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Today, we bring you critical new developments in two deeply troubling cases. We walk through the latest updates in the Ian Rogers case, including the discovery of his missing truck and the circumstances surrounding where and how it was found. We also break down newly obtained FOIA records from the Jacksonville Beach Police Department related to the case of Jonathan Hagans, documents that shed new light on law enforcement activity, timelines, and unanswered questions that remain over 50 years later.

This episode focuses on facts, records, and newly uncovered information,  separating speculation from verified detail as we continue the pursuit of truth, accountability, and awareness for the victims and their families.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18241088 Mon, 24 Nov 2025 08:00:00 -0500 1565 Ian Rogers, Jonathan Hagans 1 32 full false S1E31 - Behind the Evidence: Case Updates & Uncovered Work S1E31 - Behind the Evidence: Case Updates & Uncovered Work In this special episode, we pull back the curtain on four cases that continue to shape our investigative work: Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Michael John Olson, and Jonathan Hagans. We walk listeners through the newest updates, the leads we’ve followed, and the behind-the-scenes research that rarely makes it into the final episodes. This is a raw, transparent look at what’s moved forward, what’s stalled, and what still demands answers. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this special episode, we pull back the curtain on four cases that continue to shape our investigative work: Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Michael John Olson, and Jonathan Hagans. We walk listeners through the newest updates, the leads we’ve followed, and the behind-the-scenes research that rarely makes it into the final episodes. This is a raw, transparent look at what’s moved forward, what’s stalled, and what still demands answers. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18196090 Mon, 17 Nov 2025 08:00:00 -0500 2552 Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Michael John Olson, Jonathan Hagans 1 31 full false S1E30 - What Remains: The Hagans Siblings on Love, Loss, and the Night Jonathan Disappeared S1E30 - What Remains: The Hagans Siblings on Love, Loss, and the Night Jonathan Disappeared When Jonathan Hagans vanished, the world kept moving, but for Susan Dempsey and Joe Hagans, time stood still. Now, five decades later, they open up about what they remember from that night, how it changed their family, and the quiet strength it takes to live without answers. A tender, human look at grief that never quite lets go. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> When Jonathan Hagans vanished, the world kept moving, but for Susan Dempsey and Joe Hagans, time stood still. Now, five decades later, they open up about what they remember from that night, how it changed their family, and the quiet strength it takes to live without answers. A tender, human look at grief that never quite lets go. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18159623 Mon, 10 Nov 2025 08:00:00 -0500 1301 Jonathan Hagans, Missing Person, Jacksonville Beach 1 30 full false S1E29 - Lessons from The Laney Gwinner Effect S1E29 - Lessons from The Laney Gwinner Effect Author and teacher Randy Hubbard joins us to talk about his book The Laney Gwinner Effect, a deep look into a tragic case that continues to resonate decades later. But Hubbard didn’t stop at writing; he turned the lessons of the case into a hands-on classroom experience, guiding students through the complexities of investigative thinking. We unpack how his unique course bridges true crime, education, and community awareness. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Author and teacher Randy Hubbard joins us to talk about his book The Laney Gwinner Effect, a deep look into a tragic case that continues to resonate decades later. But Hubbard didn’t stop at writing; he turned the lessons of the case into a hands-on classroom experience, guiding students through the complexities of investigative thinking. We unpack how his unique course bridges true crime, education, and community awareness. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law


Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18121097 Mon, 03 Nov 2025 08:00:00 -0500 2011 Laney Gwinner, Randy Hubbard 1 29 full false S1E28 - HALLOWEEN BONUS - The Many Lives of James Hicks: Murder, Manipulation, and Mystery S1E28 - HALLOWEEN BONUS - The Many Lives of James Hicks: Murder, Manipulation, and Mystery James Hicks’ story is one of deception, control, and calculated violence. Convicted of murdering two women and suspected in more disappearances, Hicks’ chilling crimes span decades, leaving a trail of unanswered questions. In this deep-dive podcast, we uncover the twisted life of a man who manipulated those closest to him, examine the investigations that brought him down, and hear from the people forever impacted by his actions. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> James Hicks’ story is one of deception, control, and calculated violence. Convicted of murdering two women and suspected in more disappearances, Hicks’ chilling crimes span decades, leaving a trail of unanswered questions. In this deep-dive podcast, we uncover the twisted life of a man who manipulated those closest to him, examine the investigations that brought him down, and hear from the people forever impacted by his actions. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17833841 Fri, 31 Oct 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1980 1 28 full true S1E27 - The Space Between Words: Jack Fox and the Michael John Olson Story S1E27 - The Space Between Words: Jack Fox and the Michael John Olson Story In this episode, Jack Fox from Never a Truer Word joins us to examine how perspective (the speaker’s viewpoint, context, and intent) can alter the way we interpret statements revealed in the most recent FOIA release related to the Michael John Olson case. Together, we break down how phrasing, timing, stress, and memory can subtly shift meaning, and why even small linguistic choices, like active versus passive voice, distancing language, or what’s left unsaid, can reshape how investigators build timelines and form hypotheses. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, Jack Fox from Never a Truer Word joins us to examine how perspective (the speaker’s viewpoint, context, and intent) can alter the way we interpret statements revealed in the most recent FOIA release related to the Michael John Olson case. Together, we break down how phrasing, timing, stress, and memory can subtly shift meaning, and why even small linguistic choices, like active versus passive voice, distancing language, or what’s left unsaid, can reshape how investigators build timelines and form hypotheses. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18079023 Mon, 27 Oct 2025 12:00:00 -0400 3541 Jack Fox, Never a Truer Word, Michael John Olson 1 27 full true S1E26 - The Disappearance of Jonathan Hagans: A Brother’s Story S1E26 - The Disappearance of Jonathan Hagans: A Brother’s Story In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, Michael and Alyssa review the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans, a case that continues to haunt both family and the community.

We sit down with Joel Hagans, Jonathan’s brother, for an emotional and candid conversation about the day his brother went missing, the unanswered questions that remain, and the lasting impact on those left behind.

We also bring listeners updates from the recent vigil honoring Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers, reflecting on how their stories have united local advocates and families in their shared pursuit of justice.

Finally, we share a preview of our upcoming episode on Michael John Olson, featuring new perspectives and findings from a statement analyst who examined key details surrounding the case.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, Michael and Alyssa review the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans, a case that continues to haunt both family and the community.

We sit down with Joel Hagans, Jonathan’s brother, for an emotional and candid conversation about the day his brother went missing, the unanswered questions that remain, and the lasting impact on those left behind.

We also bring listeners updates from the recent vigil honoring Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers, reflecting on how their stories have united local advocates and families in their shared pursuit of justice.

Finally, we share a preview of our upcoming episode on Michael John Olson, featuring new perspectives and findings from a statement analyst who examined key details surrounding the case.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-18014241 Mon, 20 Oct 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1824 1 26 full false S1E25 - The Michael John Olson Case: Secrets Unlocked Through FOIA S1E25 - The Michael John Olson Case: Secrets Unlocked Through FOIA Decades after Michael John Olson vanished, the truth was thought to be buried with time, until now. Newly released documents from a Freedom of Information Act request reveal details that were never meant to see daylight. In this episode of Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast, we unpack what those files contain, question what investigators may have overlooked, and explore how these revelations could alter the course of a case long considered cold. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Decades after Michael John Olson vanished, the truth was thought to be buried with time, until now. Newly released documents from a Freedom of Information Act request reveal details that were never meant to see daylight. In this episode of Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast, we unpack what those files contain, question what investigators may have overlooked, and explore how these revelations could alter the course of a case long considered cold. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17984531 Mon, 13 Oct 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1867 Michael John Olson, Missing Person, FOIA 1 25 full false S1E24 - Interview with Meaghan Good, The Charley Project S1E24 - Interview with Meaghan Good, The Charley Project In this episode, we sit down with Meaghan Good, founder of The Charley Project, a vital online resource dedicated to cataloging missing persons cases across the United States. Meaghan shares the mission behind the project, how it has grown into one of the most comprehensive archives of its kind, and the impact it has had on both families and investigators.

We explore several cases that have been solved in part because of the project’s work and discuss the wide range of organizations, from law enforcement to journalists and researchers, that depend on this information every day. Meaghan  also reflects on the challenges of maintaining such an extensive database and why raising awareness around these stories continues to matter.

If you’re interested in true crime, missing persons investigations, or the power of grassroots efforts to make a national impact, this is a conversation you won’t want to miss.

The Charley Project - https://charleyproject.org/

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we sit down with Meaghan Good, founder of The Charley Project, a vital online resource dedicated to cataloging missing persons cases across the United States. Meaghan shares the mission behind the project, how it has grown into one of the most comprehensive archives of its kind, and the impact it has had on both families and investigators.

We explore several cases that have been solved in part because of the project’s work and discuss the wide range of organizations, from law enforcement to journalists and researchers, that depend on this information every day. Meaghan  also reflects on the challenges of maintaining such an extensive database and why raising awareness around these stories continues to matter.

If you’re interested in true crime, missing persons investigations, or the power of grassroots efforts to make a national impact, this is a conversation you won’t want to miss.

The Charley Project - https://charleyproject.org/

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17915497 Mon, 06 Oct 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1461 1 24 full false S1E23 - Interview with Jeni Decker, Host of Down and Away, Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson S1E23 - Interview with Jeni Decker, Host of Down and Away, Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson Jeni Decker, host of the podcast Down and Away, discusses her journey into podcasting, focusing on unsolved homicide and missing persons cases. She shares insights into the disappearance of Michael John Olson, highlighting the complexities and inconsistencies surrounding the case. The discussion covers the dynamics of the night Michael went missing, the role of law enforcement, and the emotional toll on the family. Jenny emphasizes the need for accurate information and the importance of community involvement in solving cold cases.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Jeni Decker, host of the podcast Down and Away, discusses her journey into podcasting, focusing on unsolved homicide and missing persons cases. She shares insights into the disappearance of Michael John Olson, highlighting the complexities and inconsistencies surrounding the case. The discussion covers the dynamics of the night Michael went missing, the role of law enforcement, and the emotional toll on the family. Jenny emphasizes the need for accurate information and the importance of community involvement in solving cold cases.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17906575 Mon, 29 Sep 2025 08:00:00 -0400 2672 podcast, true crime, missing persons, unsolved cases, Michael John Olson, Jeni Decker, Down and Away, law enforcement, investigation, cold cases 1 23 full false S1E22 - Interview with Michael's Family, Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson S1E22 - Interview with Michael's Family, Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson This episode of the Tragedy Podcast delves into the mysterious disappearance of Michael John Olson, featuring insights from his family members. They recount the events leading up to his disappearance, the challenges faced during the search efforts, and the inconsistencies surrounding the last night he was seen. The family expresses their ongoing quest for answers and closure, highlighting the emotional toll of Michael's absence over the years.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> This episode of the Tragedy Podcast delves into the mysterious disappearance of Michael John Olson, featuring insights from his family members. They recount the events leading up to his disappearance, the challenges faced during the search efforts, and the inconsistencies surrounding the last night he was seen. The family expresses their ongoing quest for answers and closure, highlighting the emotional toll of Michael's absence over the years.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17857719 Mon, 22 Sep 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1960 Michael John Olson, true crime, disappearance, family, investigation, search efforts, police response, risk factors, private investigator, community involvement 1 22 full false S1E21 - Interview with Paige Nienaber - Michael John Olson, Missing Person Case S1E21 - Interview with Paige Nienaber - Michael John Olson, Missing Person Case In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, hosts Alyssa and Michael investigate the haunting disappearance of Michael John Olson, who vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, in December 1979. They are joined by Paige Nienaber, a driving force in keeping Michael’s story alive. Together, they trace Michael’s life and the events leading up to that fateful night, recount the exhaustive search efforts, and reflect on the profound impact his disappearance had on his loved ones. The discussion explores multiple theories, the hurdles investigators faced, and the community’s enduring determination to uncover the truth, more than four decades later.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, hosts Alyssa and Michael investigate the haunting disappearance of Michael John Olson, who vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, in December 1979. They are joined by Paige Nienaber, a driving force in keeping Michael’s story alive. Together, they trace Michael’s life and the events leading up to that fateful night, recount the exhaustive search efforts, and reflect on the profound impact his disappearance had on his loved ones. The discussion explores multiple theories, the hurdles investigators faced, and the community’s enduring determination to uncover the truth, more than four decades later.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17818833 Mon, 15 Sep 2025 08:00:00 -0400 2417 Michael John Olson, missing person, true crime, West Palm Beach, investigation, family impact, search efforts, theories, community involvement, podcast 1 21 full false S1E20 - BONUS! Listener questions on the Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers cases S1E20 - BONUS! Listener questions on the Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers cases In this episode of the Tragedy, Alyssa and Michael delve into the complexities surrounding the cases of Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers. They discuss the importance of community support, the challenges of evidence collection, and the role of listener questions in driving the conversation. The episode highlights the need for consistent communication from law enforcement and explores various investigative avenues, including the significance of devices, the search for Ian's truck, and the potential involvement of local drug activity. They emphasize the importance of keeping these stories alive and encourage community engagement in the pursuit of justice.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode of the Tragedy, Alyssa and Michael delve into the complexities surrounding the cases of Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers. They discuss the importance of community support, the challenges of evidence collection, and the role of listener questions in driving the conversation. The episode highlights the need for consistent communication from law enforcement and explores various investigative avenues, including the significance of devices, the search for Ian's truck, and the potential involvement of local drug activity. They emphasize the importance of keeping these stories alive and encourage community engagement in the pursuit of justice.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17804640 Thu, 11 Sep 2025 18:00:00 -0400 1632 Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers 1 20 full false S1E19 - Sunshine State Sonar and the Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson S1E19 - Sunshine State Sonar and the Missing Person Case of Michael John Olson Today, we begin an exciting collaboration with Sunshine State Sonar to dive into one of their most compelling cold cases: the disappearance of Michael John Olson. In 1979, Olson vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, and more than 40 years later, his case remains unsolved leaving behind lingering questions and areas still waiting to be investigated.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Today, we begin an exciting collaboration with Sunshine State Sonar to dive into one of their most compelling cold cases: the disappearance of Michael John Olson. In 1979, Olson vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, and more than 40 years later, his case remains unsolved leaving behind lingering questions and areas still waiting to be investigated.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland Buzzsprout-17800013 Tue, 09 Sep 2025 08:00:00 -0400 2128 Michael John Olson, Missing 1 19 full false S1E18 - An evening with Mike Helms and his first-hand experience protecting Ted Bundy S1E18 - An evening with Mike Helms and his first-hand experience protecting Ted Bundy In this episode, we sit down with Mike Helms, a former deputy with the Leon County Sheriff’s Office who served during the investigation and trial of Ted Bundy for the Florida State and Lake City murders. Helms was part of the security team assigned to guard Bundy throughout his court proceedings while he was in custody in Tallahassee.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we sit down with Mike Helms, a former deputy with the Leon County Sheriff’s Office who served during the investigation and trial of Ted Bundy for the Florida State and Lake City murders. Helms was part of the security team assigned to guard Bundy throughout his court proceedings while he was in custody in Tallahassee.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 7f1baaf3-a31e-41bc-bbeb-21db7667c906 Sun, 31 Aug 2025 20:22:31 -0400 1581 1 18 full false S1E17 - Listener's Round Table covering the Ian Rogers Case S1E17 - Listener's Round Table covering the Ian Rogers Case Welcome to our first roundtable discussion. In this episode, we sit down with five of our listeners to hear their perspectives, answer their questions, and explore some of the theories they’ve developed after following the case.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Welcome to our first roundtable discussion. In this episode, we sit down with five of our listeners to hear their perspectives, answer their questions, and explore some of the theories they’ve developed after following the case.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 4cb12f7b-3fb5-47b8-a7c3-e5dc26261257 Tue, 19 Aug 2025 08:00:00 -0400 3301 1 17 full false S1E16 - Jody Kilgore's Birthday Celebration S1E16 - Jody Kilgore's Birthday Celebration Today, we provide a quick update on the Ian Rogers case as well as focus our efforts on getting as much participation as possible for Jody Kilgore's birthday celebration. Listen to Cyndi, Jody's sister, talk about where the event is being held and what to expect when you arrive.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Today, we provide a quick update on the Ian Rogers case as well as focus our efforts on getting as much participation as possible for Jody Kilgore's birthday celebration. Listen to Cyndi, Jody's sister, talk about where the event is being held and what to expect when you arrive.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland cf0af3fb-699a-4260-9a93-8888c2ac44e2 Tue, 12 Aug 2025 08:00:00 -0400 988 1 16 full false S1E15 - Meeting with IRIS - Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E15 - Meeting with IRIS - Murder of Jody Kilgore On today's very special podcast, we meet with Kathy Decker and Douglas MacGregor. They belong to an organization named IRIS that offers specialty investigative services to law enforcement. We get their take on what they do and how they could provide a new look at the Jody Kilgore case. - https://irisinvestigativestrategies.com/

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> On today's very special podcast, we meet with Kathy Decker and Douglas MacGregor. They belong to an organization named IRIS that offers specialty investigative services to law enforcement. We get their take on what they do and how they could provide a new look at the Jody Kilgore case. - https://irisinvestigativestrategies.com/

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 5c42e0b4-5ded-4c6a-a120-cdb21ee84eea Tue, 05 Aug 2025 08:00:00 -0400 2603 1 15 full false S1E14 - Theories about the disappearance of Ian Rogers S1E14 - Theories about the disappearance of Ian Rogers This is our last episode in the Ian Rogers series. Here we discuss our theories and final thoughts as well as meet with Teresa, Ian's mom one last time.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> This is our last episode in the Ian Rogers series. Here we discuss our theories and final thoughts as well as meet with Teresa, Ian's mom one last time.

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 4a547b3a-b130-4a1b-960e-4a35ee63dbef Tue, 29 Jul 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1764 1 14 full false S1E13 - Interview with Depths of History - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E13 - Interview with Depths of History - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case We speak with Britain Lockhart, the owner of Depths of History. He walks us through the mission of his organization, the type of work he engages in and his role in the search for Ian Rogers. 

Depths of History YouTube Channel - https://www.youtube.com/@depthsofhistory 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> We speak with Britain Lockhart, the owner of Depths of History. He walks us through the mission of his organization, the type of work he engages in and his role in the search for Ian Rogers. 

Depths of History YouTube Channel - https://www.youtube.com/@depthsofhistory 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland b5576f51-15f1-4ce6-960c-6ae54abb134b Tue, 22 Jul 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1589 full false S1E12 - Interview with North Florida Diving Services - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E12 - Interview with North Florida Diving Services - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case Meet Justin Hembrock. He is the owner of North Florida Diving Services. Justin shares with us his efforts so far on the Ian Rogers case, an overview of what his company can offer, and the need for more information to help bring Ian home.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Meet Justin Hembrock. He is the owner of North Florida Diving Services. Justin shares with us his efforts so far on the Ian Rogers case, an overview of what his company can offer, and the need for more information to help bring Ian home.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 270b2d79-fa76-4fe6-88e1-bcb698d31504 Tue, 15 Jul 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1502 1 12 full false S1E11 - Conversations with Joe Webster and Dan Ellis - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E11 - Conversations with Joe Webster and Dan Ellis - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case We had the privilege to speak with Joe Webster, the owner of Spartan Exteriors and Dan Ellis, one of his best friends that also worked for Joe. They provide some interesting details about their relationship with Ian and about the day Ian disappeared. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> We had the privilege to speak with Joe Webster, the owner of Spartan Exteriors and Dan Ellis, one of his best friends that also worked for Joe. They provide some interesting details about their relationship with Ian and about the day Ian disappeared. 

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 0fa7551c-6500-452f-ac8c-3adbcd40feb5 Tue, 08 Jul 2025 17:18:35 -0400 845 1 11 full false S1E10 - Interview with Sunshine State Sonar - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E10 - Interview with Sunshine State Sonar - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case We had the unique opportunity to meet with Shelly McKinney, a member of Sunshine State Sonar. She shares with us the details of the organization and the work that was put into searching for Ian Rogers.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> We had the unique opportunity to meet with Shelly McKinney, a member of Sunshine State Sonar. She shares with us the details of the organization and the work that was put into searching for Ian Rogers.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland f923795d-7fe3-45c0-b6b2-0a372125dfda Tue, 01 Jul 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1961 1 10 full false S1E9 - Interview with Kaylee Evans - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E9 - Interview with Kaylee Evans - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case Today, we speak with Kaylee Evans, Ian's girlfriend. She shares her thoughts about Ian and the details she recalls about day of his disappearance.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Today, we speak with Kaylee Evans, Ian's girlfriend. She shares her thoughts about Ian and the details she recalls about day of his disappearance.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 6fda4293-8cc2-415c-b29a-68d047c63ef1 Tue, 24 Jun 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1544 1 9 full false S1E8 - Interview with Teresa Rogers - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case S1E8 - Interview with Teresa Rogers - Ian Rogers Missing Person Case Today, we speak with Teresa Rogers, Ian's mother. She shares her thoughts on Ian, on what happened that day, and what she needs from all of us to help find her son.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Today, we speak with Teresa Rogers, Ian's mother. She shares her thoughts on Ian, on what happened that day, and what she needs from all of us to help find her son.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 6f0bfb53-b62f-4d13-8b51-1ecdef371f3b Tue, 17 Jun 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1549 1 8 full false S1E7 - Ian Rogers - Missing Person Case Review S1E7 - Ian Rogers - Missing Person Case Review This is the initial case review of missing person, Ian Rogers. There is not a lot known about what transpired that day, but a case that started out as a missing person investigation has quickly escalated to a criminal investigation. 

YouTube Coverage From Depths of History - https://youtu.be/NdyqyZ-Q5r4?si=jdbwCVvYrt0diO7Q

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> This is the initial case review of missing person, Ian Rogers. There is not a lot known about what transpired that day, but a case that started out as a missing person investigation has quickly escalated to a criminal investigation. 

YouTube Coverage From Depths of History - https://youtu.be/NdyqyZ-Q5r4?si=jdbwCVvYrt0diO7Q

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 69027f6a-7ad7-4b2f-b09b-a14d024f2410 Tue, 10 Jun 2025 08:00:00 -0400 996 1 7 full false S1E6 - A Mother's Burden - The Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E6 - A Mother's Burden - The Murder of Jody Kilgore We had the pleasure to speak with Jody's Mother, Gladys Kilgore. She shares her thoughts and feelings about Jody and the case, we wrap up a few theories from episode 5, and we create come calls to action for the community and the Wakulla County Sheriffs Office.

Facebook Group - https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100064648934127

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> We had the pleasure to speak with Jody's Mother, Gladys Kilgore. She shares her thoughts and feelings about Jody and the case, we wrap up a few theories from episode 5, and we create come calls to action for the community and the Wakulla County Sheriffs Office.

Facebook Group - https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100064648934127

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 804ea30f-6b85-4c65-96d3-905598c66ba8 Tue, 03 Jun 2025 08:39:32 -0400 1568 1 6 full false S1E5 - Not the First Time - Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E5 - Not the First Time - Murder of Jody Kilgore We decided to revisit a theory based on listener feedback, discovered more details around possible drug connections and recapped a story with some interesting parallels to Jody's murder.

Mike Williams Case - https://youtu.be/jqeOxhQrh9k?si=C11byATK2sV5rwH_

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> We decided to revisit a theory based on listener feedback, discovered more details around possible drug connections and recapped a story with some interesting parallels to Jody's murder.

Mike Williams Case - https://youtu.be/jqeOxhQrh9k?si=C11byATK2sV5rwH_

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland e071ce0c-e76e-4694-9f41-2399702df196 Tue, 27 May 2025 08:00:00 -0400 1704 1 5 full false S1E4 - Stepping into the Tornado (Theories and Rumors) - Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E4 - Stepping into the Tornado (Theories and Rumors) - Murder of Jody Kilgore In this episode, we discuss several theories and rumors that swirl around Jody's unsolved homicide.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we discuss several theories and rumors that swirl around Jody's unsolved homicide.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland cf4a6c9e-4cb2-4efb-a817-1bdbba3cf3e8 Tue, 20 May 2025 18:30:29 -0400 2287 1 4 full false S1E3 - Community Event in 2023 - Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E3 - Community Event in 2023 - Murder of Jody Kilgore In this episode, we recap the community event at Palavar Tree Theater. We hear from the family, law enforcement and from the Kilgore's private investigator. What do we learn? What do we feel is missing?

Footage of the event - https://www.facebook.com/share/v/193qmSw56i/

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we recap the community event at Palavar Tree Theater. We hear from the family, law enforcement and from the Kilgore's private investigator. What do we learn? What do we feel is missing?

Footage of the event - https://www.facebook.com/share/v/193qmSw56i/

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland d6b98af0-6ae6-46b2-9f1d-e24b80d8212f Tue, 13 May 2025 18:03:18 -0400 1725 1 3 full false S1E2 - Interview with Robin Stevens - Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E2 - Interview with Robin Stevens - Murder of Jody Kilgore In this episode, we talk with Robin Stevens, Jody's sister. She shares a little about her life, her relationship with Jody, and her thoughts on the day Jody was murdered.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we talk with Robin Stevens, Jody's sister. She shares a little about her life, her relationship with Jody, and her thoughts on the day Jody was murdered.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland 63a84112-10a3-4c48-b48e-6028b9bdb881 Tue, 06 May 2025 22:11:28 -0400 2736 1 2 full false S1E1 - Case Summary of the Murder of Jody Kilgore S1E1 - Case Summary of the Murder of Jody Kilgore In this episode, we are going to review what we have found regarding the events that have been reported the day of Jody's murder. We will discuss what is currently known, and talk about rumors and speculations that might be relevant or possible barriers to solving this case.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> In this episode, we are going to review what we have found regarding the events that have been reported the day of Jody's murder. We will discuss what is currently known, and talk about rumors and speculations that might be relevant or possible barriers to solving this case.

As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law

Support the show

Thank you for listening.

Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

]]> Michael and Alyssa McFarland c51fee02-67b3-4616-a586-15ad343cf365 Tue, 29 Apr 2025 21:34:51 -0400 1337 1 1 full false